Lil’ Wayne – Tha Carter III [Review]

thacarter3-cover-nappyafro

1992 had The Chronic from Dr. Dre, 1993 had Doggystyle from Snoop Dogg, 1994 had Ready To Die from The Notorious B.I.G., 2001 had The Blueprint from Jay-Z, and 2008 had Tha Carter III from Lil’ Wayne. If you didn’t catch that, those were all the most anticipated album releases of the respective years. 2008 isn’t any different as Lil’ Wayne has had the most anticipation for an album release, even surpassing the same day album release battle hype between Kanye West and 50 Cent for their Graduation and Curtis albums last year. You can’t watch TV, listening to the radio, or surf the Internet without hearing about Tha Carter III’s upcoming release in some form or another. As a result of Weezy’s recent comments about mixtape DJs and their need in the rap game, DJ Chuck T decided to leak the official album on the Internet for listeners and fans to download at will. Despite this, I think Wayne will still go on to sell millions and go platinum with this release, regardless of the leak attempt/revenge (Wayne fans are going to download and purchase the album…so it’s pretty much a win/win for Weezy). The hype and anticipation for this album has been well built over a span of 3 years since his previous album release (Tha Carter II) and numerous guest appearances. Does the album live up to the hype though? It is a certified classic or certified collision course…Let’s see Dr. Carter!

3 Peat
Produced by Maestro
The beat provided by Maestro immediately gives this track that “introductory” feel to it, similar to past tracks like “I’m Me” (The Leak EP) or “Tha Mobb” (Tha Carter II). Wayne drops some nice aggressive sounding lyrics on this track, clearly stating his position and making his presence known to listeners. This is the official introduction of Tha Carter III to the public with Wayne stating this is a three-peat like the 90’s Chicago Bulls dynasty. This is a nice way to start off the album and leaves you prepared for the rest to come.

Mr. Carter
Featuring Jay-Z; Produced by Infamous
Being a huge Jay-Z fan, when I saw this track on the track listing I was excited and anticipated a great track. Upon listening to the track my anticipation was fulfilled as this track starts off great with some very nice subtle production from Infamous. I can remember how excited I was about “Hello Brooklyn 2.0” on Jay-Z’s American Gangster album, and how very disappointed I was with it after hearing the song (the worst song on American Gangster in my opinion). Nonetheless this song makes up a lot for the previous offering from the two and this is how their collaboration should have been the first time. Without a doubt Jay-Z spits some very ill lyrics on this track, but Wayne not to be out done gets down for the crown and stands toe to toe with Hov in terms of lyrics. Glad to hear that this is the fifth single for the album, and I hope they make a great music video for it with Wayne and Jay-Z featured together in it.

A Milli
Produced by Bangledesh
This is the official second single for the album and it’s a song that has been constantly played on the radio, and I sure that most listeners have heard it plenty of times. Bangledesh is able to cook up an interesting sounding beat for this track that goes well with Wayne “freestyle” sounding delivery. This song is a pretty good one, but has gotten old now and won’t be getting a lot of play from me. I’ve heard it enough on the radio and won’t be listening to it that much in playing the album.

Got Money
Featuring T-Pain; Produced by Play-n-Skillz
This track is the official third single off the album and it has that club feel to it. Featuring the maestro of Auto Tune on the hook in T-Pain, Wayne spits lyrics that are fitting for a song of this type and they do what they are supposed to do. I’m not really feeling the production from Play-n-Skillz on this track, as it sounds kind of generic especially from the synths that they use. This is an average song in my opinion that will most likely get play in the clubs and radio. This is the first track on the album that I’m not really feeling and will probably skip a lot when playing.

Comfortable
Featuring Babyface; Produced by Kanye West
What!? Babyface on a track with Lil’ Wayne, I never thought I would see the day of that happening. But I ain’t trippin’ cause he truly adds to this track and makes it that much better. The production by Kanye West on this song really sounds like some vintage Kanye beats from his College Dropout days, and that’s the kind of production that he does best (not a lot of this heavy-snyth/techno sounding stuff he has done lately). Wayne sounds very comfortable spittin’ over this track and doesn’t sound out of place at all on this type of track. I can clearly say that this is one of my favorite tracks on the entire album, if not my favorite. This one has been on repeat for a while and is top quality in my opinion.

Dr. Carter
Produced by Swizz Beatz
Right off the back I must say that Swizz did his thing with the production on this track in sampling David Axelrod’s “Holy Thursday” to near perfection. Wayne delivers a very creative track in the theme/topic of this track in him playing a doctor who is operating on various artists in the industry trying to save them. If you really listen to what he’s saying he’s actually on point with a lot of the statements he’s making about the rap game and music industry. I love the fact that after unsuccessfully saving the first two artists/patients, he is able to save the last one from dying which happens to be “Hip-Hop”. That’s some clever thinking on Wayne’s part to create a song like this that shows his creativity as an artist when a lot of people claim to rarely see them in him. I would enjoy seeing a music video made to this track, it would be some creative shit to watch.

Phone Home
Produced by Cool & Dre
The team of Cool & Dre provides some sci-fi sounding production on this track, which is the point judging by the song title and direct reference to the movie E.T. Wayne is dropping some rhymes on this track explaining how he’s a Martian and not off this world. I can understand where he was trying to go with this track, but unfortunately he missed the mark on this one. The chorus is really poor on this track, especially the person yelling “phone home” throughout it. This track is a skip in my opinion.

Tie My Hands
Featuring Robin Thicke; Produced by Kanye West
Once again Kanye West returns with some nice and smooth music production on this track. Weezy hooks up with Robin Thicke again for another great collaborative effort. This track seems them picking up where they left off with “Shooter”. It sounds more like a Robin Thick song than a Lil’ Wayne track, and I wouldn’t be surprised if Robin Thicke included it on his album as well. Wayne really drops some knowledge on his second verse with lines like these: They tried to tell me keep my eyes open/My whole city under water, some people still floatin’/And they wonder why Black people still votin’/Cause your president still jokin’/Take away the football team, the basketball team/Now all we got is me to represent New Orleans/No governor, no help from the mayor/Just a steady beatin’ heart and a wish and a prayer. That’s some real truth right there spoken by Weezy and should really be heard by everyone. This is a perfect example of why people shouldn’t just write off Wayne as an artist who doesn’t rap about anything. You can tell that he’s very passionate about his hometown and everything they have been through and are still struggling with. This is another favorite track of mine of this album that will get many spins from me.

Mrs. Officer
Featuring Bobby Valentino; Produced by Deezle & Wyclef Jean
This is an interesting song by Wayne with him talking about his escapades and thoughts about having sex with a female police officer. Even though it’s a clever track with it topic/theme, it still comes off sounding your average track for the ladies. Bobby Valentino singing on the hook does what it’s supposed to do in further talking to the ladies, but the song kind of gets stale after a while of listening. Deezle & Wyclef Jean provide some nice production for this type of track and it does its job. This song isn’t a skip, but it’s kind of close to it for me.

Let The Beat Build
Produced by Kanye West
I know that they were trying to stay true to the song title with the production on this track in letting the beat build up throughout the song, but it gets very repetitive really quickly. Wayne isn’t really saying much on this track, but he does a nice job in switching up his flow during the song. The hook on this track is horrible and more thought should have been put into it than just what it is. This track is a skip for me and I won’t find myself listening to it much.

Shoot Me Down
Featuring D. Smith; Produced by Kanye West
The beat provided by Kanye on this track fits nicely with Wayne’s flow and delivery as it sounds very personal. The singing by D. Smith on the song’s hook is a nice addition, and it makes it sound like a Lupe Fiasco or Kanye West type track. This song is nice for it’s build-up, as Wayne’s flow and delivery get more aggressive as the song nears its end. It has a similar feel to Wayne’s “Gossip” track (The Leak EP).

Lollipop
Featuring Static Major; Produced by Deezle & Jim Jonsin
Okay, everybody and their momma has heard this song on the radio or seen the video on their favorite music video television program like 106 & Park or TRL. This song, which was the first official single for the album, like “A Milli” has been played to death and has gotten old after hearing it so much. Just like “A Milli”, this will be a song that doesn’t see much play from me just because I’ve heard it so much already. Despite that, this is an interesting type of song from Wayne and one I was surprised to see as his first single for the album when it was released. I was wondering what Wayne was on when I first heard this song, but after a while this song kind of grew on me and it did its job in building much anticipation for the album. The only question I have is why Deezle & Jim Jonsin sampled the music/sound effects from the game show Deal Or No Deal. When I first heard this song I said to myself, “those are definitely the sound effects from Deal Or No Deal” (Ha!).

La La
Featuring Brisco & Busta Rhymes; Produced by David Banner
This track could have been done without on this album, as it sounds absolutely ridiculous with the “childlike” sounding production by David Banner. None of the artists on this song are really saying any spectacular or amazing, which makes this song even less interesting. This track is definitely a skip for me, and sounds like it should have been put on one of Wayne’s many previously released mixtapes instead of being placed on the album.

Playing With Fire

Featuring Betty Wright; Produced by StreetRunner
I know that I said earlier that the track “Shoot Me Down” sounded like Wayne’s “Gossip” track off his EP The Leak, but I think this track exemplifies that even more. Seeing as how StreetRunner, who also produced “Gossip”, handles the production, it gives off an epic kind of feel and blend well with Weezy’s lyrics and intensity/energy. Even though it’s similar to “Gossip” it’s not better than that track, as Wayne’s lyrics don’t really grab your attention like they did on the previous track, especially when you saw him perform it live for the first time at the BET Awards. This is an average track in my opinion and nothing more than that.

You Ain’t Got Nuthin’

Featuring Fabolous & Juelz Santana; Produced by The Alchemist
The Alchemist delivers his trademark sounding production on this track, which sort of works at times throughout the song. It might be just me but the production gets kind of boring to listen to after a while and it kind of takes away from the potential that this track had with Wayne, Fab, and Juelz all on a track together. Lyrically, all three emcees spit some nice rhymes, but the feel of the track makes it feel like a mixtape track instead of an album cut. Some better production would have made this track work much better.

Don’t Get It (Misunderstood)
Produced by will.i.am
After three average/mediocre tracks, Wayne closes out the album on a more personal note with an excellent finale to the project. The production from will.i.am is good on this track, but it comes off as kind of bland seeing as how the same kind of beat and song was done by Common with the song “Misunderstood” on his Finding Forever album. After two verses from Wayne, the proceeds to explain how people in the hood are really just misunderstood individuals. Think of Kanye West’s “Last Call” when you think about this track in ending off the album.

 

Bottom Line:
So in the end does C3 (Tha Carter III) live up to its hype and anticipation? Yes it most certainly does. Lil’ Wayne was able to continue his success from Tha Carter II and further build upon it into a product just as good. Is Tha Carter III the best album of 2008? It’s only June so it’s too early to determine that, especially knowing how the 4th quarter in the rap game is. Personally, I don’t think it’s the best album released in 2008 so far cause there have been some better released before this album, but I definitely think it’s one of the top albums of 2008 without a doubt. Despite the album being leaking, this album will still see some of the highest sales for a rap album in a very long time considering the state of the buying trends for rap albums. I can confidently say that this album will go platinum in its first week (and that’s a bold statement nowadays), but Wayne has the fans and support to do so. Wayne will no doubt have plenty of support from his die-hard fans, and I think he will be able to garner even more fans with this album. A lot of people, specifically “Hip-Hop Heads” have written off Wayne as just a commercial, pop-rap artist that’s just following the trends in the music industry, but I think that Weezy is much more than that if you really give him a chance. Yeah all artists have their commercial tracks and club songs (who doesn’t nowadays), but when Wayne wants to talk serious and spit the truth especially about the conditions of his hometown New Orleans, he can definitely lay claim to “The Best Rapper Alive” or at least the heir to the throne (that is once Hova really does retire from the rap game). This album had some low points, but there were more good points to be found and that’s what makes this album worth purchasing even if you aren’t a big Lil’ Wayne fan. Wayne has produced a great album right here that is sure to please various audiences with its range of songs from “Lollipop” to “Comfortable” to “Mrs. Officer” to “Dr. Carter”. There’s something to be found and liked by everybody off this album even if it’s not the entire album, and in the end that’s really what a great album is supposed to do and how you recognize one.

nappyPicks: “Comfortable”, “Mr. Carter”, “Tie My Hands”, “Dr. Carter”, “Lollipop”, & “A Milli”

Download: Lil’ Wayne feat. Robin Thicke – “Tie My Hands”

4stars

  1. i been letting alot slide bc it didnt have noting to do with me. but u sayin this isnt the best album of the year .. COME ON. X-cuse wayne 4 not waiting until late november to drop an album so he has time to steal sample off other people music to make sure his is better .. (Yea thats what jay z does) this is the best album n most anticipated album in recent memory. be honest when as the last time u knew the released date 4an album without looking it up. its crazy that u thought he missed his mark on “phone home” the only reason u think that bc the arrow went thru the bull eyes… lil wayne has past all expectations as a rapper n is now taking over music.. jay z wanna be him now 1st he steals his flow from weezyaveli then he come out with ” a billie” i thought it was a remix with micheal jackson.. bottom line. jay z living hes past thru the future of weezyaveli… KRS-1 sucks ass. n Cincinnati bengals r great
    Go Georgia !!
    SBK ( Should Be Killed) get real or get gone.
    Weezyaveli 4 life. nighas

  2. Lil Wayne has did the damn thing on this album. This is one of his best albums, this is the best album of 08. It haven’t been too many good albums out this year, Rick Ross wasn’t all that, Bun B joint was nice.. I think Wayne stole the show. I’ll say this album is around 4-4 1/2 stars. 500 Degreez had to be Wayne worst album, and then Lights Out. Wayne is killing the game right now, there is nobody in the game right now who is really killing the game right now. I have to agree with Slik P, I thought Phone Home was decent, it was different… At least his album wasn’t filled up with songs like Gucci Mane, Shawty Lo, and alot of them wanna be trapper rappers crappers music. The Carter III could have been a tad bit better if he would have taken off that song with T-Pain. The Dr. Carter beat is the same beat that Fat Joe had on “Jealous One Envy” (1995), same sample, and break beat but Swizz Beats kinda arranged it a little bit differently.

  3. playing with fire is amazing, the passion and, well, insanity, in weezy’s lyrics are ridiculous.
    best songs are- shoot me down, playing with fire, mr. carter, and dont get it

  4. tha carter 3 is tha shit. i think that tha album would be way better if half tha album wasnt leaked late 2007 cuz if those songs were on the album and he got rid of sum songs then it would have been more of a 4.5/5

  5. To those hailing this as the best hip hop album of 08….I’d think it’s better to say best MAJOR Label Mainstream hip hop album of 08 at the moment

    Wayne’s lyrics are great on this album, but really it’s the big time producers who made the tracks that make this album as it is IMO.

  6. lil wayne is NOT THAT GOOD! Phone Home was garbage, again: Only somebody like Lupe Fiasco could flow a topic like that. This album was WAY overhyped, a 3.5 tops!

  7. The whole album is hot just stimulate ur mind and listen again if you aint feelin it (its a classic ppl)

  8. He gave the shit 4 stars folks want 6. Yes, 6 outta 5. lol. Wane is one of the most entertaining rappers alive, but best rapper, nah.

  9. 4 / 5? I’m not too sure about that one. Y’all back on that dickriding shit. The only reason why it’s half decent is because of the production. HIs lyrics are off point throughout the entire album. There is no real theme to the Carter III and his usual simile raps just bore the shit out of me. Out of 12 albums I’ve listened to this year, I have to say this is near the bottom.

  10. mufucka, this isn’t a concept album, so there doesnt necessarily need to be an overall theme.

    To those saying it’s a classic, you are goin over the top. Unlike albums such as “Paid in Full”, “raising Hell”, “Illmatic”, and a hell lot more albums considered classics, this one does not bring anything new to the game, but is a pretty enjoyable album.

    I may find this album better than what other people think of it though because I was one of those few who had low expectations for it lol

  11. Ok I agree with your opinion on all the other tracks except for Playin With Fire…

    That song has so much intensity to it…if I don’t feel like cleaning the house…i play that shit…grab the broom…and start rappin the part about him being on the same balcony as MLK did with heart and shit…i would love to see that part in a music video…

    great review tho!

  12. 4 Stars is where this album needs to be. The more I listen to every song, well almost every song, the better they get. Let the Beat Build is definently not a skip.

  13. I agree Comfortable is one of the best tracks on the album but you’re craaaaazy for calling Let the Beat Build a skip, it may be the hardest track on there next to Mr. Carter

  14. Good Review… You Kept it Real… I Would Have Given It 4.5 Stars IMO… I Liked Every Song Except Mrs. Officer And It’s Not Bad, Just Not For Me… Over The Past Year, I Had Become One Of The Biggest Wayne Haters On The Planet… But This Honestly brought Him back To My Top 5… This Nigga Used Syllables On Almost Every Song!!! When 3 Peat Came On And This Nigga Went To Spitting That Fire And Pronouncing His Words… I Was Sold! 4.5/5….

  15. are we listening to the same album? this cd just was not hot. Wayne needs focus there are hot songs on this album but you have to skip through so much crap to get to them. and comfortable is TRASH

  16. some u guys is crazy. classic? hell no. best album of 08 yet? very possibly. more than 4 stars? no. got money was horrible, and so was la la and phone home had a good concept, just bad execution. 13/16 average to great songs is not classic. it equates to 4 stars. on par review sbk.

  17. Best rapper alive? it wuz straight but his mixtapes songs were better. the way they was hypin this album up i would of thought it wuz better than young jeezy last album. big dissapointment maybe people will now get off his jock

  18. Man tha carter 3 was good. i love all these niggas sayin that it was shit and the producers made it and his lyrics are wack. but the funny thing is he is getting paid millions of dollas and you are buying his cd. so he obviously got your attention. dumb niggas. dont hate cuz he making the money. and your money at that ha stupid ass niggas. imma bump to lil weezy ta death mayne.

  19. Mr. Jones… Kanye Aint Weezy… And I Hate To Sound Like A Dick Rider But… Weezy Is Weezy. Like I Said Earlier, He Tapped A Huge Audience For C3. Even Niggas Livin Under A Rock Dun Heard Somethin Bout It, If not Enough To Buy It…. He Gon Catch 3….

  20. I am talking about sales bro. They are selling about the same amount. So I predict that despite nearly a mil in a week, this STILL won’t go 3 plat.

  21. can someone explain how you like songs like “3PEAT” and “PLAYING WITH FIRE” when his lyrics were barely understandible??? “SHOOT ME DOWN” was “Ok” but overrated by the way “LET THE BEAT BUILD” is the best song on the album . i agree with you about the beat on “nuthin on me” but the lyrics was fire and “LALA” wasnt that bad busta killed it

  22. 3 Peat…. “Barely Understandible”?? Damn, You Must Have A low Quality Bootleg My Nigga!!! Wayne Didn’t Miss A Syllable On That Intro/Song. He Delivered Perefect For A Track 1…

  23. wow i can’t believe ppl r really callin this album a classic. r u serious?? this album had some hot tracks (like 3peat, tie my hands, tie my hands) but it had alotta pretty average ones and even some trash ones (wat hell was he thinkin wit phone home?? and his lyrics in la la are awful) i swear dude was so lazy wit this album. alotta his similes and punchlines ain’t even clever no more (like tha number after 1, ima get me 2) and to tha reviewer, as a matter of fact ain’t got nuthin on me WAS a mixtape song called gangsta walk wit jus fab and cassidy so how it even ended up on here is kinda weird. tha album was straight but it wasn’t on point like most of his mixtape tracks be. he coulda tried harder.

  24. yeah they are mr. jons. if youve been on the net you mustve seen/heard dozens of people callin c3 a classic. he aint talkin bout big name reviewers, just small time ones and commenters

  25. Ok mr. asshole jones, I can spell just fine, thank you. I was just typing like that because it’s faster and I’m used to typing quickly. And sese is right, no major reviewers (besides Rolling Stone, smh) have really dubbed it a classic, but a couple of online ones, those replying to threads like these and some others are saying it’s a modern day classic, which is crazy.

  26. I think it’s a classic. It’s a classic “Lil’ Wayne” album… where you get “gansta walk” from? “Aint Got Nuthin On Me” came out as “Aint Got Nuthin On Me” bout 4 months ago…. only difference is the kermit/ad lib line in Fabolous’s verse and the beat was a tiny bit smoother on the Original…

  27. People who are saying this is a big disappointment went too far. This album has a some serious lyrical heavy hitters. The first half of the album is well above average, except Got Money. The second half the tracks tail off a bit though especially 3 before DontGetIt. I think this review is fair. Kanye did his thing on comfortable, gotta love those old school smooth beats.

    4/5

    “Man I got summer hating on me cause I’m hotter than the sun
    Got Spring hating on me cause I ain’t neva sprung
    Win-ter hating on me cause I’m colder than ya’ll
    And I will neva I will neva I will neva FALL
    I’m being hated by the season
    So fuck ya’ll who hating for no reason”

  28. oh, well there’s a song called gangsta walk i downloaded and it’s just with fabolous and cassidy. same fab verse, beat and everything. but yea, it’s shorter and the beat doesn’t change like it does for lil wayne’s part.

  29. This album did not live up to its hype..R yall fuckin serious. Its not better than the carter 1 or 2. This is album is nowhere to a classic. Bun B and Plies album is way better than this shit. Its not horrible but it wasnt worth 10.81 n i’ve been listenin to wayne since before the block is hot. He need to work on stayin on subject when he rhymes,get back wit h Manny Fresh, and work on his fuckin hooks. Cuz a couple of his hooks where trash like the one with sanatan and fabolous. He first 3 songs u think you r about to hear a classic, then u hear a whole bunch of average songs. ITS NOT A CLASSIC

  30. Does anybody give a fuck about Rolling Stone? hahahahaha

    Anyways, not a classic, but the best of Wayne’s discography, and damned good.

  31. The tracks were very we’ll produced, the album was entertaining enough to make me stop and laugh for quite a while
    I enjoyed the entire album…if anything you guys are crazy for hatin so hard and need to chill out with all that.
    Tha Carter 3, excellent job.

  32. Wayne Didn’t Build The Hype…. His Fans Did For Thinkin He Was Jesus Reincarnated. It Wasn’t Possible To Please His Fans With The Carter III…

  33. can some of yall lil wayne stans clear up something for me cause some of his rhymes didnt make since ……like the second verse of mr.carter when he said i suck a p^ssy f^ck a p^ssy leave it swell . what the f^ck did that have to do with the rest of what he was saying???? and please explain to me how you like 3peat ??? his lyrics was even more off topic and didnt go together

  34. @ Biggs

    If You Want To Find Understandin in Every Rhyme, Wrong CD…. Damn Man! You Can’t Let Simple Shit Like That Kill A Song! If The “Suck A Pussy” Line Was Taken Off, Would The Song Have Been Any Degree Better or Worse? Not At All.

    And 3 Peat Didn’t Have A Topic! It Was Hype/Intro Song! It Was Just Wayne Reminding Us That The He Still Can Rap Like Back in The Day….

    You Analyzin’ Too Much Homie…

  35. @ v-g

    so if you admit this is the wrong cd to be listening to for understanding …then you would agree this is a dope album but NO CLASSIC ???

  36. That’s Not What I Meant… Wayne Aint Gon Solve Any Life Mysteries on C3! Haha I’m Just Sayin That Not Every Verse or Line Gon Make It Into The Rap Bible, If That Makes Sense… Some Lines Are Just Not That Important And You Gotta Overlook It For The Grand Scheme.

    And I Don’t Skip Songs When I Listen To C3. I Like All Of Them Honestly. As Long As it Sounds Good, I Can Enjoy It. It Almost Ruins The Song To Try To Analyze The Lyrics When You Can Jus Let It Ride!

  37. The Carter 3 was a good cd for w Wayne. But not close to a classic. It deserves a 3.5 or 4. The best album in 08 is the Carter 3 and Bun B 2 thrill is close. But The Game, Young Jeezy, Nas, and Busta come out this year so weezy won’t have the best cd of 08.

  38. WTF? Theres a few songs i will jam off this, and that would be the ones with the R&B artists, like Comfortable, Shoot Me Down, And Tie My Hands..Dr. Carter was also nice..Mr Carter was not as good as it shoulda been, and the more i listen the moe i notice taht the production made this album not necessarily waynes lyrics, cuz he didnt spit to much hot shit..Bun’ Album was better than this and MM4 from Cham will def bebetter..Cham wrecked A Millie way harder then Weezy and he go hard on Here ..Check yaself
    Chamillionaire.com

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *