Kanye West – My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy [Review]

Kanye West returns with his fifth release in nearly seven years. The name was changed from Good Ass Job to My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. I’m not sure if this had something to do with Roc-A-Fella records or if Kanye just felt it was time to finally let go of the school series. No matter what the album was going to be called, it has been the most hyped record for the last couples of months. This resulted from Kanye’s weekly drops of his G.O.O.D. Friday series. Since then, there has been Monster Mondays, Wu-Wednesdays, and probably several other free download schemes. However, nothing has come close to topping G.O.O.D. Friday. Kanye has collaborated with legendary icons such as Pete Rock, RZA, Q-Tip and several more. If that was only a preview of what Kanye had in store, then My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy should be ground breaking.

1. Dark Fantasy
Narrated by Nicki Minaj; Produced by RZA, Kanye West, & No I.D.
Kanye starts the album with a small skit that sounds like it came from a different century. The music comes thirty seconds in with a Mike Oldfield sample of “In High Places”. The chorus has a real choir-like tone and it sounds as if it’s going to be an interlude, but (I’d imagine) RZA drops a heavy beat with drums and keys that are reminiscent of the early Wu days. RZA was one of Kayne’s inspirations and this beat definitely shows it. This is a perfect way to start the album.

2. Gorgeous
Featuring Kid Cudi & Raekwon; Produced by Kanye West, No. I.D., & Mike Dean
The rhythm of this track builds with an electric guitar and Kid Cudi laying down the chorus. Kanye is not known for his lyrical abilities, but he drops heat on his second verse:

“Is Hip-Hop just a euphemism for a new religion, the soul music of the slave that the youth is missing, but this is more than just my road to redemption, Malcolm West had the whole nation standing at attention”

Kanye goes off for the next three verses before Rae gets his chance on the mic. I never thought I’d say this, but I think Kanye West just outshined Raekwon The Chef.

3. POWER
Featuring Dwele; Produced by Kanye West, Jeff Bhasker, Mike Dean, & S1
“Power” was the first song to be put on wax from the album. The track starts with a clap from Continent Number 6’s “Afromerica” and a lively King Crimson sample of “21st Century Schizoid Man”. The nicely-mixed beat immediately gives the song a powerful melody. On the opening bars, Kanye states:

“I’m livin’ in that 21st century, doin’ somethin’ mean to it, do it better than anybody you ever seen do it, screams from the haters, gotta nice ring to it, I guess every superhero need his theme music”.

Finally, soul singer Dwele drops some additional vocals to give the song more depth. This unquestionably is one of the best produced songs of the year.

4. All Of The Lights (Interlude)
Produced by Kanye West
Kanye displays that he’s musically gifted in more ways than one. Here, he lets his hands do the talking as he mixes in a violin with a lovely set of keys. Beautiful work Mr. West.

5. All Of The Lights
Featuring Rihanna, Alicia Keys, Charlie Wilson, Elly Jackson, Elton John, Fergie, John Legend, Kid Cudi, Ryan Leslie, The-Dream & Tony Williams; Produced by Kanye West & Jeff Bhasker
I would imagine this is the song you’ll be hearing on the radio for the next couple of months. The song is supposed to contain several guest appearances (Alicia Keys, Charlie Wilson, Elly Jackson, Elton John, Fergie, John Legend, Kid Cudi, Ryan Leslie, The-Dream,  & Tony Williams), but I only hear Rihanna on the hook. Kanye shows us how to make an Akai MPC drum machine thump with a set of hard hitting drums followed with ecstatic horns and heavy keys. The only thing I didn’t like was the unnecessary verse by Fergie.

6. Monster
Featuring Rick Ross, Jay-Z, Nicki Minaj, & Bon Iver; Produced by Kanye West, Mike Dean, & Plain Pat
Kanye is joined at the mic with Rick Ross, Jay-Z, and Nicki Minaj. Bon Iver’s Justin Vernon gets things going by singing about his dark twisted fantasy. Rick Ross steps up to the mic first, and drops a hot verse:

“Bitch, I’m a monster, no good blood sucker, fat motherfucker, now look who’s in trouble, as you run through my jungles all you hear is rumbles, Kanye West samples, here’s one for example.”

Kanye does a nice job with his verse:

“And my eyes more red than the devil is, and I’m about to take it to another level biz, don’t matter who you go and get, ain’t nobody cold as this, do the rap and the track, triple double – no assists, and my only focus is staying on some bogus shit, arguing with my older bitch acting like I owe her shit”.

Jay-Z waits his turn until absolutely murdering it:

“Sasquatch, Godzilla, King Kong, Lochness, goblin [goo], a zombie with no conscience,
Question – what does these things all have in common,
Everybody knows I’m a motherfuckin’ monster,
Conquer, stomp ya, stop ya silly nonsense,
[Naissance], none of you niggas know where the swamp is,
None of you niggas have seen the [cogence] that I’ve seen,
I still effin’ scream in my dreams,
Murder murder in black convertibles,
I ahh, kill the block, I murder the avenues,
I ahh, rape a pillage of village women and children,
Everybody wanna know what my Achilles heel is,
Love, I don’t get enough of it, all I get is these vampires and blood suckers,
All I see is these niggas I made millionaires,
[Million] about spilling their feelings in the air,
All I see is these fake fucks with no things, trying to draw blood through my ice cold fangs,
*Sniff* I smell a massacre, seems to be the only way to back you bastards up”

Nicki Minaj is the last to get on the mic and she does a decent job:

“So let me get this straight, wait I’m the rookie, but my features and shows ten times your pay, 50k for a verse, no album out, yea my money so tall that my Barbie gotta climb it”.

Lastly, Bon Iver’s Justin Vernon expands the track with some more auto-tuned singing. I rate this as a standout, but I felt that Nicki’s 16 should have been better when you compare it to Kanye’s & Jay’s.

7. So Appalled
Featuring Jay-Z, Pusha T, Prynce CyHi, Swizz Beatz & RZA; Produced by Kanye West, No I.D., & Mike Dean
“So Appalled” was released on the G.O.O.D. Friday series. No I.D. & Mike Dean help Kanye co-produce the track. This beat was structured for an emcee slaughterhouse. It’s not hard to tell that Kanye West has seriously stepped up his emcee game. He’s flowing like he got his swagger back since we last heard him on 808’s & Heartbreak. Jay-Z gets on next and does what he does best – murder it. Jay is strictly ridiculous on this album. He’s rhyming like he still has something to prove:

“How should I begin this, I’m so offended, how am I even mentioned by all these fuckin’ beginners, I’m so appalled, I might buy the mall, just to show niggas how much more I have installed, I’m fresher than ya’ll, so I don’t have to pause, all of ya can suck my balls through my drawls”.

The Clipse’s Pusha T does a nice job with his verse speaking on the success he’s had as a rapper. Newcomer emcee Prynce CyHi surprisingly keeps up with the heavy hitters. I was hoping to hear RZA drop a verse, but he only handles the last (unnecessary) bridged chorus.

8. Devil In A New Dress
Featuring Rick Ross; Produced by Bink! & Mike Dean
I love the soulful sample by Smokey Robinson that Bink! & Mike Dean use throughout the song. This track was previously released a couple months ago on the G.O.O.D. Friday series. This time around, Kanye adds Rick Ross to the mix. I didn’t agree with this decision… until I actually heard it. Rick Ross’ laid back flow is the perfect fit. This may be my favorite song on the album.

9. Runaway
Featuring Pusha T; Produced by Kanye West, Emile, Jeff Bhasker, & Mike Dean
The track begins with a striking key that later alters into the beat. This song is about the woman. On Kanye’s verse, he speaks about all of the mistakes he’s had with women over the years. Pusha T takes a different approach about how there are plenty of fish in the sea:

“Hoes like vultures wanna fly in your Freddy loafers, you can’t blame them they never seen Versaci sofas, every bag, every blouse, every bracelet comes with a price tag, baby face it, you should leave if you can’t accept the basics, plenty hoes in a ballin nigga’s matrix, invisibly set, the rolex is faceless, I’m just young, rich and tasteless, P!”.

Before the track ends, Kanye adds auto-tuned sound effects for four more minutes. It doesn’t take anything away from the song but it’s really unnecessary.

10. Hell Of A Life
Produced by Kanye West, Mike Caren, No I.D., & Mike Dean
The track starts by sampling Mojo Men’s “She’s My Baby”. The drum machine really bangs out here. The bizarre auto-tuned chorus (that follows the vibes of Black Sabbath’s “Iron Man”) really gives the song an up-tempo feel. This is probably one of the least lyrical songs on the album, but the production still makes it above average.

11. Blame Game
Featuring John Legend & Chris Rock; Produced by Kanye West, DJ Frank E, & Mike Dean
Kanye takes a sample from Aphex Twin’s “Avril 14th” and reenergizes it with more tuned keys. John Legend accompanies the beat by singing about the blame game on the chorus. Kanye gets more emotional and speaks on his downfalls with love. Lately, Kanye has been releasing a lot of music about his women problems, but this by far is my favorite track on the topic. Chris Rock finishes the track with some comedy about the teachings of Yeezy. After hearing this, I’m really looking forward to that Kanye West & John Legend collaboration.

12. Lost In The World
Featuring Bon Iver; Produced by Kanye West & Jeff Bhasker
The track starts with a Bon Iver auto-tuned sample. The techno-pop beat comes in after the sample. This is another track that is predominantly beat sided. At this point, I’m feeling that all the different sounds are getting played out. In my opinion, the track alone holds the album back from its full potential of ever being considered a classic.

13. Who Will Survive In America
Produced by Kanye West & Jeff Bhasker
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy wraps up with a revolutionary skit by Gil Scott-Heron about who will survive in America. The speech is appropriate for the theme and is the perfect way to end the album.

I’ll admit that I wasn’t expecting My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy to be this good. For one, we already heard five songs from the G.O.O.D. Friday series and the production lineup seemed to get cloudy right before the release. However, he saved some of his best gems for this record. Right now, Kanye is at the top of his production game. He has the ability to create so many different sounds whether he’s using a drum machine, piano, violin, electric guitar, keyboard or any other instrument he may come across. One of the main reasons why I won’t give this a“Classic Material” rating is because of the lyrical content. Not to say that Yeezy hasn’t improved since his earlier years, but his lyrics are still questionable from time to time.

When I compare My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy to his other releases, I’d rate this par with College Dropout and Late Registration. However, I’ll agree with P-Body and say this is his third best release. It doesn’t seem to have that Hip-Hop feeling that his first two albums had. When comparing the album to other 2010 releases, I’d definitely say it’s in the top 5 (possibly top 3 behind Distant Relatives and How I Got Over).

Finally, Kanye is not going to take a break anytime soon. He along with Jay-Z plan to release Watch The Throne hopefully in early 2011. After hearing Jay on “Monster” and “So Appalled”, I expect their collaboration LP to be epic.

  1. this was close to a 4.5. It was a couple tracks I wasn’t feeling, but that is just because of MY musical taste. Graduation is still better, but ALL of Kanye’s albums are tight! This nigga is a LEGITIMATE musician.

    Ross killed that verse in “Devil in a New Dress”

  2. I have to co-sign with Jerm. This album is good but some stuff didn’t grab me all the way like when I first heard his albums years back. Nothing really jumped out at me as much as the first few albums did. This is definitely one of the albums of the year by far! Don’t get me wrong with the comment because the album is good but for Kanye catalog it wasn’t better than the first two albums to me.

  3. Oh yeah @ Arkitekt

    Thanks for the shout out. Definitely a third best release from Kanye. People are really overhyping this album to me.

  4. It’s crazy you think Nicki Minaj didn’t go that hard on “Monster”. All my friends think she did, I’m the only one who doesn’t.

    I think this is the album we look back on five years later as one of the greatest things to ever come out of hip-hop. Right now, it’s just a contender for Album of the Year. But one day it’ll get it’s due.

  5. I’ll come back and read the full review when I get back, but I wanted to see the rating right quick. I thought this would have been our first 5star review. This album is classic imo and I think that this will be, like someone else said, the album that lasts from this time period.

    1. Read the review, DAMN thorough job fam. Great job. My take:

      Artists are a special group of people. Of that group, there are a talented few that are able to turn their life and experiences into something epic. We’ve watched Kanye rise up from car accidents, relationships, stupid mistakes, triumphant defiance, personal loss and overall turmoil. He’s used all of that experience to create his best album to date. While there is a thin line between genius and insanity, Kanye is riding that line with the grace of a ballerina with this album. The album is titled correctly in every way, beautiful, dark, twisted, and fantastic.

      5 stars

  6. Just bought this, every track is great except for Monster.
    For the rest,
    I fully agree with P-body.

    This album was great, the album of the year for me.
    But it is a little bit overhyped, (pitchfork gave this album a 10!), because his first 2 albums (CD & LR) were better.
    I think MBDTF is better than Graduation and FOR SURE is better than 808 & heartbreak.

    1. College Dropout
    2. Late Regristration
    3. My Beautifull Dark Twisted Fantasy
    4. Graduation
    5. 808 & heartbreak

      1. hahahhahai knew what you were talkin bout. btw whoever, its i still hear feins scream in my dreamslol not effin scream. no offense it just doesnt even sound like that.

  7. What do you mean Kanye has never been known for his lyrical ability? Kanye has always been good lyrically he has nice punchlines, flow and the substance to keep you listening. If you don’t think Kanye was good lyrically before you need to go listen to his old albums again. Also I think you are overrating Jay’s verses a little bit, especially his verse on So Appalled which was good but I think Kanye’s was better, also you said Rick Ross had a hot verse which I feel couldn’t be any farther from the truth.
    But this was a good review I’m just pointing out things that I disagree with, I’m definitely buying this tommorow

    1. Glad someone pointed that out. Kanye not known for lyrical ability???

      FOH.

      We all know Kanye is a beast with the mic.

      1. I grew up listening to Kool G Rap, Rakim, Ice Cube, KRS-One, BCC, Wu-Tang. Kanye is not even close to that level in my opinion, but he’s a good commerical rapper. Same can be said about Dr. Dre, he may sound better than he actually is b/c he’s the one shaping the beat around his vocals. Thanks for the props rickjamesbitch.

        1. Woah, please don’t compare Kanye west to Dre lyrically! Ye is far better! But I see where you’re coming from but..

          “I had a dream I could buy my way to heaven, when I awoke I spent that on a necklace”

          “Gimmie, ten seconds, I’ll have a buzz bigger than insects in texas”

          “Killing yall niggas on that lyrical shit, mayonaisse color benz I push miracle whips”
          He might not be able to to hang with the guys you mentioned but he is definitely a top tier mainstream rapper.
          And after listening to the album I have to say I completely agree with your review, especially the part about Lost In the World holding the album back and Rick Ross on Devil in a New Dress.

  8. Overall 4.5 is definitely a good rating. I very rarely see an album that is 5 mics or stars. Seriously even the classics back in the day I still jam to sometimes I consider them 4.5 stars at the most. 5 stars would mean that everything is perfect which is a lie.

  9. Pretty good album, better than what I expected from Kanye.
    But album of the year status? I don’t think so… I’d rate both Roots albums, Distant Relatives, To All My Friends (Atmosphere, I know it’s a collection of EPs but so was Lucy Ford, and that’s arguably one of their best, so Friends is still a contender IMO), PackFM’s I Fucking Hate Rappers, KNO’s Death is Silent and Stimulus Package (although I’m REALLY not a fan of Birdman or Young Chris, thankfully, they don’t do a significant amount of damage to their respective songs) higher than Fantasy….but that may be cos I don’t like the guests featured on this album, especially Minaj, Fergie and Ross.

    Anyhow, I will concede that this probably the best Mainstream release of the year.
    Also, great review Arkitek, it was very well written and informative:)

  10. The album started out great (besides All Of The Lights) but once it got past Runaway I lost all interest because it lost that hip hop feel to it. I could have sworn Premo said this was going to be some of his hardest stuff to date?

    Sorry but this is far from Classic. And who calls something classic when its only been out for days? FOH! Classics need to stand the trials of time. I remember some of us called The Recession a classic, and it was a banger of an album but no where near classic now that you take a look back.

    Within my top 5 of releases for 2010(mixtape and album wise) along with Friday Night Lights with So Appalled being my favorite on this album

    1. Yea, I agree that people need to kill that classic noise. If this is a classic, then there is well over 300 classic hip hop albums. There really hasn’t been an “instant” classic since the 90s. Give it some time people!

    2. I think it depends on what kind of classic you’re talking about. The Chronic was a classic albeit not a 5star classic album. What it meant to hip hop and that time period was bigger than the album itself. I think this one may be that way as well. While I feel it has grown increasingly tougher to appreciate work and label it classic because our attention span has gotten undeniably shorter, some albums are bigger than the release. With increased pressure to conform to cliche tricks, gimmicks, and methods to cater to radio and video, Kanye steps out and creates an album with attitude and purpose and does so, flawlessly in my opinion.

      1. well said! I’m a firm believer that no album can be considered perfect all around cause people have different tastes in music. but if the majority of an album is universally accepted and ages well it should be given classic status.

  11. I mostly agree with the review, but I think Lost In The World is underrated. Also, I can’t stand All Of The Lights. I feel like Ye kinda rushed to get this out there and missed a few mistakes – but he would claim it’s artistic license.

  12. yo does anyone know wat he did to everyone’s voices? the leaked tracks sounded realer, on the album its…weird…higher pitched i guessed

  13. Great review Ark, I’m pretty much in agreement with what you said

    to me tho this could never be a Classic Album for one reason: that damn intro from Nicki.

    eghck.

  14. everybody so quick to tag an album as “classic” or “never be a classic cuz of blah blah” stfu and just listen to it.

  15. just got this today

    Smoke a bowl and listen to this. You will never be the same

    That collab album with him and Jay-Z is going to be sick

  16. I just bought this today and im about to pop this in the cd player

    I’m in space the final frontier courtesy of this Grandaddy Purp so it should be a smooth listen

  17. Coming back to this album 2 years laters, I have to conclude that this is Kanye’s best album. When it first came out, I did not want to believe that this was better than his first two albums. As I’ve had time to digest this as much as i’ve digested College Dropout and Late Registration, this album trumps those two in nearly every way.

    Lyrically, Kanye has grown with each album. This album contains some of the best bars that Mr. West has even spit. “Too many Erkel’s on your team, that’s why your wins-low (winslow)” and “Get caught with 30 rocks the cop look like Alec Baldwin” are just two prime examples of the evolution that Kanye has experienced as an MC. His story telling has also improved in songs like “Hell of a Life”, and “Blame Game”. The former being about him falling in love with a porn star, and the latter about a relationship gone wrong. While Late Registration and College Dropout are no slacks on lyricism either, this album trumps both of those lyrically.

    Production wise, this album is one of the biggest sounding albums i’ve ever heard. It’s The Dark Knight Rises of hip hop albums. The only way to describe the production is to call it Epic. The beats are layered and are composed perfectly. While we have clear hip hop beats in “Dark Fantasy”, “All of the Lights”, and ” Devil in a New Dress”, we have some beats that truly test the barrier between hip-hop, pop, and rock in “Power”, “Monster”, “Hell of a Life”, and “Lost in the World”.

    Let’s look at Lebron James for a moment, he played like absolute garbage in the 2011 NBA Finals. He took the most heat (no pun intended) out of anyone on that team. His self-induced pain inspired him to come back even harder than ever before. He dominated the regular season like he normally does, but once the playoff came, he performed even greater. Because of this performance, he won his first NBA title and was named Finals MVP. Kanye got drunk, went onstage, embarrassed Taylor Swift, and became the most hated man in America. He took some time to think about his actions, came back with a vengeance, and released his most personal, most ambiguous, and greatest album ever. Years from now, people will recognize the greatness of this album.

  18. Coming back to this album 2 years laters, I have to conclude that this is Kanye’s best album. When it first came out, I did not want to believe that this was better than his first two albums. As I’ve had time to digest this as much as i’ve digested College Dropout and Late Registration, this album trumps those two in nearly every way.

    Lyrically, Kanye has grown with each album. This album contains some of the best bars that Mr. West has even spit. “Too many Erkel’s on your team, that’s why your wins-low (winslow)” and “Get caught with 30 rocks the cop look like Alec Baldwin” are just two prime examples of the evolution that Kanye has experienced as an MC. His story telling has also improved in songs like “Hell of a Life”, and “Blame Game”. The former being about him falling in love with a porn star, and the latter about a relationship gone wrong. While Late Registration and College Dropout are no slacks on lyricism either, this album trumps both of those lyrically.

    Production wise, this album is one of the biggest sounding albums i’ve ever heard. It’s The Dark Knight Rises of hip hop albums. The only way to describe the production is to call it Epic. The beats are layered and are composed perfectly. While we have clear hip hop beats in “Dark Fantasy”, “All of the Lights”, and ” Devil in a New Dress”, we have some beats that truly test the barrier between hip-hop, pop, and rock in “Power”, “Monster”, “Hell of a Life”, and “Lost in the World”.

    Let’s look at Lebron James for a moment, he played like absolute garbage in the 2011 NBA Finals. He took the most heat (no pun intended) out of anyone on that team. His self-induced pain inspired him to come back even harder than ever before. He dominated the regular season like he normally does, but once the playoff came, he performed even greater. Because of this performance, he won his first NBA title and was named Finals MVP. Kanye got drunk, went onstage, embarrassed Taylor Swift, and became the most hated man in America. He took some time to think about his actions, came back with a vengeance, and released his most personal, most ambiguous, and greatest album ever. Years from now, people will recognize the greatness of this album.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 192 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here